Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • Lisa Noell  Profile Image
    The best Erie Agency in Lynchburg!

    “The best Erie Agency in Lynchburg! I deal directly with Andy Mathews; he is very professional, very knowledgeable in all aspects of his business, upfront and honest! His staff is awesome. They take care of me with great customer service and professionalism. I would highly recommend the Andy Mathews Agency and Erie Insurance for all your insurance needs.”

  • MM
    ...been professional and helpful throughout our relationship.

    “ I have been with Andy since he started. He has been professional and helpful throughout our relationship. He has anticipated my needs and reviews my policies regularly. I could not ask for a better agent ”

  • DM
    Our family has been with Andy Mathews Agency for years. We couldn't be happier

    “ Our family has been with Andy Mathews Agency for years. We couldn’t be happier with the level of service and attention we get ”

  • SS
    They are there for you anytime you...

    “They are there for you anytime you ask”

  • MM
    Always there when I need it. Great

    “Always there when I need it. Great service.”

  • PC
    The staff at Andy's office are friendly and helpful.

    “The staff at Andy’s office are friendly and helpful. They work to find the best deal available providing what you need without going overboard. ”

  • JB
    Owning a Driving School, the State is ALWAYS wanting proof of insurance

    “Owning a Driving School, the State is ALWAYS wanting proof of insurance verification & bond verification. I can always get a copy of any needed paperwork provided from either location or sent via email to me. ”

  • GA
    ...has taken care of my accounts for years.

    “Michael has taken care of my accounts for years. Always handles things promptly! Just super friendly, helpful and professional. ”

  • AB
    ...so helpful in meeting our insurance needs.

    “Michael was so helpful in meeting our insurance needs. Always ready to answer any questions that we may have.”

  •  Mark Mason Profile Image
    Great service, very helpful, and very competitive rates.

    “Great service, very helpful, and very competitive rates. Thanks Andy and Michael!”