Find Out How Much You Can Save Today

First Name*
Last Name*
Email*
Phone*
Type of Insurance*
Additional Info
Phone
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get a Quote

Andy Mathews Agency

Insurance Services
About
Policy Service
Contact

Get In TOuch

Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

The best Erie Agency in Lynchburg!Lisa N., Lynchburg, Virginia
“The best Erie Agency in Lynchburg! I deal directly with Andy Mathews; he is very professional, very knowledgeable in all aspects of his business, upfront and honest! His staff is awesome. They take care of me with great customer service and professionalism. I would highly recommend the Andy Mathews Agency and Erie Insurance for all your insurance needs.”
MM
...been professional and helpful throughout our relationship.Mike M., Lynchburg, Virginia
“ I have been with Andy since he started. He has been professional and helpful throughout our relationship. He has anticipated my needs and reviews my policies regularly. I could not ask for a better agent ”
DM
Our family has been with Andy Mathews Agency for years. We couldn't be happierDoodoo M., Lynchburg, Virginia
“ Our family has been with Andy Mathews Agency for years. We couldn’t be happier with the level of service and attention we get ”
SS
They are there for you anytime you...Sadegh S., Lynchburg, VACustomer since Jun 2013
“They are there for you anytime you ask”
MM
Always there when I need it. GreatMichael M., Monroe, VACustomer since Feb 2018
“Always there when I need it. Great service.”
PC
The staff at Andy's office are friendly and helpful.Phillip C., Lynchburg, VACustomer since Aug 2007
“The staff at Andy’s office are friendly and helpful. They work to find the best deal available providing what you need without going overboard. ”
JB
Owning a Driving School, the State is ALWAYS wanting proof of insuranceJames B., Madison Heights, VACustomer since Jun 2015
“Owning a Driving School, the State is ALWAYS wanting proof of insurance verification & bond verification. I can always get a copy of any needed paperwork provided from either location or sent via email to me. ”
GA
...has taken care of my accounts for years.Gary A., Madison Heights, VACustomer since Jan 2011
“Michael has taken care of my accounts for years. Always handles things promptly! Just super friendly, helpful and professional. ”
AB
...so helpful in meeting our insurance needs.Arnold B., Vesuvius, VACustomer since Feb 2019
“Michael was so helpful in meeting our insurance needs. Always ready to answer any questions that we may have.”
Great service, very helpful, and very competitive rates.Mark M., Madison Heights, VA
“Great service, very helpful, and very competitive rates. Thanks Andy and Michael!”
EW
Lynchburg, VACustomer since May 2020
“I spoke to Wendy for my insurance needs and she was wonderful, she made me feel like I was becoming part of a family not just a number on a price of paper. It was a fast quote and I was happy with the service. I would recommend them to all my friends. ”
PN
Lynchburg, VACustomer since Jun 2007
“Always there for us with the right answer to all of our questions.”
GJ
Georgia J., Waldorf, MDCustomer since Aug 2002
“Andy has always provided me with excellent advice and has been responsive to questions that I may have ”
JV
Joshua V., Rustburg, VACustomer since Sep 2019
“Nicer people to deal with and way better prices.”
DP
Deborah P., Madison Heights, VACustomer since May 2020
“Prompt and courteous service. Very friendly and accommodating and saved us over $4000.00. Am very pleased with the entire experience. They make you feel welcome and care about their customers.”

1
…
17

Andy Mathews Agency

Rated 4.9 out of 5 based on 26 rated reviews.

We Want Your Opinion!

Write a Review

Home > Customer Reviews

About

About Us
Meet Our Staff
Customer Reviews
Our Insurance Carriers
Insurance Blog

Insurance

Auto, Home, & Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
Life & Health Insurance

Policy Service

Policy Service Center
Online Billing & Payments
File A Claim
Policy Change Request

BrokerCheck by FINRA

Lynchburg Office

Andy Mathews Agency

20566 Timberlake Road
Suite B
Lynchburg, Virginia 24502

Phone: (434) 534-9004

Fax: (434) 534-9331

Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

Google Maps Yelp Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Madison Heights Office

Andy Mathews Agency

5068 South Amherst Hwy
Suite 110
Madison Heights, Virginia 24572

Phone: (434) 847-4340

Fax: (434) 847-4350

Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

Google Maps

Andy Mathews Agency Provides Auto, Homeowners, Business/Commercial, Life, and Health Insurance to All of Virginia, Including Bedford County, Campbell County, Appomattox County, Halifax County, Pittsylvania County, Amherst County, and the city of Lynchburg.

Insurance Agency Websites